Best Pizza in Fort Lauderdale? (Local’s Advice!)

Looking for outstanding pizza in Fort Lauderdale? You’re in for a treat! Our guide takes you straight to the heart of the city’s pizza scene, delivering a slice of local favorites and hidden gems. From waterfront decks with signature thin crusts to quaint parlors with rich deep-dish fare, prepare for a delicious dive into the doughy goodness Fort Lauderdale has to offer.

Pizza in Fort Lauderdale

  • Fort Lauderdale is a pizza lover’s paradise, with a diverse selection of authentic pizza styles from classic New York and Chicago to unique twists like Detroit ‘Mom’s Spaghetti’ pizza.
  • Local favorites like Osteria Aqua e Farina and Vincent’s Italian Kitchen stand out with their gourmet toppings and secret sauces, while locations like Times Square Pizza offer budget-friendly deals satisfying cost-conscious cravings.
  • Beyond a great variety of pizza, Fort Lauderdale hosts special events like pizza making classes and the annual Fort Lauderdale Pizza Festival, bringing the community together for pizza, craft beers, and fun activities.

Discovering Fort Lauderdale’s Pizza Paradise

A variety of delicious pizzas on display

Fort Lauderdale, a pizza haven, offers a wide array of styles to suit every taste. The city’s restaurants serve everything from the classic New York slice to the hefty Chicago or Detroit-style pizza, and even unique variations influenced by different cities.

Some of the city’s most notable pizza joints include:

  • Sicilian Oven: a local favorite known for its authentic Italian pies
  • Primanti Bros.: offers an old Italy-style pizza experience
  • Blue Steel Pizza Co.: offers a unique Detroit-style pizza experience, with standouts like the “Mom’s Spaghetti” pizza that features spaghetti and meatballs on top!

A Slice of New York in FL

New York-style pizza joints in Fort Lauderdale, known for their thin, crispy crusts and generous toppings, are certain to satisfy your cravings. Big Louie’s Pizzeria, located near Sunrise Blvd, serves up authentic New York-style pies that have gained a loyal following.

From the Joey D with meatballs, ricotta cheese, and parmesan shavings, to the Hit Man with sausage, garlic, red peppers with a spicy kick, Big Louie’s Pizzeria has a vast selection of delicious pizzas. And if you’re really hungry, try their enormous 18-inch pizza – a true New York-style marvel right here on Federal Highway in Fort Lauderdale.

Neapolitan Nirvana on Las Olas Blvd

Wood-fired pizza oven on Las Olas Blvd

Pizzeria Magaddino on Las Olas Blvd is the go-to place for an authentic Neapolitan slice. This bustling eatery is renowned for its Neapolitan pizzas, which are all about thin crusts that puff up at the edges, giving a light and delicate vibe.

The menu at Pizzeria Magaddino is packed with a variety of Neapolitan pizzas, catering to different tastes. From pizzas with red sauce to white sauce and even vegan options, there’s something for everyone. A must-try is the Street Corn pizza, topped with cream sauce, confit garlic, and spicy mayo, offering a unique twist to the traditional Neapolitan pizza experience.

Chicago Cravings Satisfied

Those craving a taste of Windy City pizza won’t be disappointed in Fort Lauderdale. The city is home to several pizzerias specializing in Chicago-style thin crust pizza, known for its round and thin crust that’s baked longer for that extra crispy finish.

Establishments like:

  • Chicago Stuffed Pizza
  • Blue Steel Pizza
  • Il Baretto
  • Jet’s Pizza

are some of the best places to satisfy your Chicago-style cravings. The Villa Rose special is a must-try, offering a taste of true Chicago-style thin crust pizza. Add to that the Tare brothers, Tony and Spartak, who run La Fontana, and you’re in for a treat.

The Wood-Fired Wonders of Fort Lauderdale

Gourmet wood-fired pizza with fresh toppings

Fort Lauderdale has perfected the art of making comforting wood-fired pizzas. The city boasts a number of pizzerias that use wood-fired ovens, imparting a unique flavor to their pizzas. Notably, Osteria Aqua e Farina and Vincent’s Italian Kitchen stand out with their gourmet toppings and secret sauces, ensuring that their pizzas are extra special.

At Osteria Aqua e Farina, the toppings are the stars. Think tuna-watermelon sashimi with jalapeno and lime or Berkshire crispy pork belly with huckleberry jam and farro.

Over at Vincent’s Italian Kitchen, the secret’s in the sauce. Their special red sauce is a blend of fresh garlic, white onion, and Tuttorusso canned tomatoes, giving their wood-fired pizzas a unique punch of flavor.

Osteria Aqua e Farina: Gourmet Toppings Galore

At Osteria Aqua e Farina, pizza is more than just a meal; it’s a culinary adventure. This restaurant is known for its thick and chewy crust pizzas topped with fresh mozzarella and an array of gourmet toppings, such as seafood and homemade pasta, that elevate the flavor of their pizzas.

With a rating of 4.5 out of 5 on Tripadvisor, Osteria Aqua e Farina is highly regarded by locals and tourists alike. It’s all thanks to Giovanni Rocchio, the chef and owner, who is the creative force behind the restaurant’s amazing gourmet pizzas.

Vincent’s Italian Kitchen: A Secret Sauce Sensation

At Vincent’s Italian Kitchen, pizza is a craft taken seriously. This restaurant stands out for its use of imported Caputo 00 Italian flour, top-grade Grande cheese, and a secret red sauce, all baked to perfection in a Stefano Ferrara wood-burning oven.

The restaurant’s secret red sauce, prepared with:

  • extra virgin olive oil, including a hint of truffle oil
  • onion
  • celery
  • carrot
  • fresh basil leaves
  • homemade passata

is a testament to their commitment to quality and flavor. This dedication is reflected in every bite of their pizzas, making Vincent’s Italian Kitchen a must-visit spot for pizza enthusiasts.

Budget Bites: Best Pizza Deals Around Town

Beyond gourmet pizzas and high-end dining, Fort Lauderdale also caters to those seeking budget-friendly pizza options. Of course, being a major city, they have every one of the major pizza chains in the area.  So if that’s your thing, you can find the usual joints.  Personally, I only do this when I’m feeding a lot of mouths and want to save money!

Whether you’re looking for a quick slice and soda combo or a full meal deal, Fort Lauderdale has you covered. Some budget-friendly pizza options in Fort Lauderdale include:

  • Pizza Hut
  • Domino’s Pizza
  • Little Caesars
  • Papa John’s

These options provide affordable and delicious pizza for those on a budget.

From Emmy Squared Pizza to Las Olas Pizza and Jet’s Pizza, there are plenty of spots offering wallet-friendly pizza options. So, whether you’re on a tight budget or just love a good deal, these pizzerias are sure to hit the spot without breaking the bank.

Slice and Soda Steals

Times Square Pizza provides a budget-friendly option with their unbeatable deal: two slices and a soda can for a mere $6. This combo is perfect for those looking for a quick bite on a budget.

But that’s not all Times Square Pizza has to offer. Their Family Pizza Night Special, which includes 1 large cheese pizza, 1 baked pasta, and 6 garlic knots for $23, and the Big Apple Special, which includes two 16-inch one topping pizzas, wings, and large fries for $50.45, are also great value for money options.

So, no matter what you’re in the mood for, Times Square Pizza has a deal for you.

Signature Slices: Pizzas That Are Talk of the Town

Several pizzerias in Fort Lauderdale are famed for their signature pizzas. Louie Bossi’s Ristorante and El Tamarindo, for instance, are just a couple of the many Fort Lauderdale restaurants known for their unique flavors and high-quality ingredients.

Louie Bossi’s Ristorante is renowned for its unique take on classic pizzas, using top-notch ingredients like prosciutto di Parma, San Marzano tomatoes, and fresh mozzarella.

At El Tamarindo, the pizza has a unique doughy crust smothered in a thick layer of well-baked cheese and sweet tomato sauce, making it a standout choice for pizza lovers.

Louie Bossi’s Ristorante: Margherita Mastery

At Louie Bossi’s Ristorante, the Margherita pizza is a fan favorite. Layered with a vibrant San Marzano sauce, basil, sea salt, and imported fior de latte, a soft and buttery buffalo mozzarella, it’s a masterpiece of Italian culinary tradition.

With a rating of 4.5 out of 5 on Tripadvisor, Louie Bossi’s Ristorante is a popular choice among locals and tourists alike. The man behind the success of this restaurant is none other than Louie Bossi himself, who ensures the quality of their signature pizzas by sourcing ingredients locally and making everything from scratch.

El Tamarindo’s Cheese Crown

El Tamarindo offers a unique pizza experience with its Cheese Crown pizza. This pizza stands out with its doughy crust smothered in a thick layer of well-baked cheese and sweet tomato sauce.

With a rating of 4.5 out of 5 on Tripadvisor, El Tamarindo is a must-visit for pizza lovers. The restaurant is run by brothers Antonio and Juan Carlos, who ensure that each pizza is crafted with care and precision, resulting in a truly memorable dining experience.

Gluten-Free and Vegan Varieties

Pizza in Fort Lauderdale is a delight for everyone. The city’s pizzerias cater to a wide range of dietary preferences, offering gluten-free and vegan options without compromising on taste. Whether you’re a health-conscious eater or have dietary restrictions, the city ensures that you can indulge in a slice without worry.

From Blaze Pizza to YOLO Restaurant and Phil’s Heavenly Pizza, there are plenty of spots offering gluten-free pizzas. For vegans, Pizzeria Magaddino and Sarpino’s Pizzeria offer vegan pizzas, ensuring that everyone can enjoy a slice of pizza heaven.

Health-Conscious Havens

Catering to dietary restrictions, a number of pizzerias in Fort Lauderdale offer gluten-free and vegan pizza options. These pizzerias go the extra mile to ensure that those with specific dietary needs can enjoy a slice without worry.

For gluten-free options, Luigi’s Coal Oven Pizza and Emmy Squared Pizza are top choices, while Pizzeria Magaddino and Plant Pizza offer vegan-friendly pizzas. These establishments ensure that even those with dietary restrictions can enjoy a delectable pizza experience in Fort Lauderdale.

Late-Night Pizza Haunts in Lauderdale

luigis coal oven pizza
Luigi’s is on the east end of Las Olas next to Rocco’s Tacos. Coal Fired Pizza!

Late-night cravings for a slice are well catered for in Fort Lauderdale. The city is home to several pizzerias that stay open till midnight and beyond, ensuring that late-night hunger pangs are well catered to.

From Primanti Brothers Restaurant to Luigi’s Coal Oven Pizza and Pummarola Fort Lauderdale, there’s no shortage of options when it comes to late-night pizza haunts. So whether you’re wrapping up a night out or just in the mood for a midnight snack, these pizzerias have got you covered.

Open Till Midnight and Beyond

For those who prefer their pizza after dark, Fort Lauderdale offers a number of pizzerias with extended hours of operation. Whether you’re looking for a late-night snack or a post-midnight feast, these pizzerias have you covered:

  • Pizza Time
  • Big Louie’s Pizzeria
  • Primanti Bros.
  • Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza
  • Pizza Fusion

Places like Primanti Brothers Restaurant offer a chill and cozy atmosphere where you can kick back and savor some delicious pizza, even late into the night. With a variety of pizza options to cater to different tastes, even in the late hours, these late-night pizza joints ensure that your midnight cravings are well satisfied.

Alfresco Pizza Experiences

The beautiful weather in Fort Lauderdale makes it an ideal city for outdoor dining. Many of the city’s pizzerias offer patio seating, allowing you to enjoy your favorite slice under the Florida sun or beneath the stars in Fort Lauderdale FL.

Whether you’re looking for a cozy spot for a lunchtime pizza or a romantic setting for a dinner date, pizzerias like Dolce Salato Pizza & Gelato, Primanti Brothers Restaurant, and Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza offer a great outdoor seating atmosphere. So why not take your pizza experience outdoors and soak up the lively atmosphere of the city?

Patio Pleasures on Andrews Ave

Andrews Ave in Fort Lauderdale is a hotspot for alfresco pizza dining. Here, you’ll find several pizzerias with patio seating, serving up delectable pizzas in a relaxed outdoor setting.

Establishments such as Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza & Wings, Emmy Squared Pizza – Fort Lauderdale, Manhattan NY, and Blaze Pizza offer a unique dining experience on Andrews Ave, just a short distance from Oakland Park Blvd. Whether you’re looking for a quick lunch or a leisurely dinner, these pizzerias offer a great mix of excellent pizza and a relaxed outdoor ambiance.

From Oven to Doorstep: Top Pizza Delivery Services

When you wish to savour a delicious slice at home, Fort Lauderdale’s pizza delivery services are at your disposal. These services offer the convenience of having your favorite pizza delivered straight from the oven to your doorstep.

Whether you’re ordering from Uber Eats, Vito’s Gourmet Pizza, or Ariel’s Delicious Pizza, these delivery services ensure that your pizza arrives hot and fresh. Plus, with the ability to track your order and see the estimated time of arrival, ordering pizza has never been easier.

The Ease of Ordering Online

In today’s digital age, ordering pizza is just a click away. Many pizzerias in Fort Lauderdale offer online ordering, making it easier than ever to satisfy your pizza cravings.

Whether you’re ordering from Domino’s, Papa John’s, or Sarpino’s, these pizzerias offer simple steps to pick your pizza and get your order sorted. Plus, with delivery options available, you can enjoy your favorite pizza without even leaving your home.

Pair Your Pie: Drinks and Sides to Complement Your Pizza

A pizza meal isn’t whole without the complement of an ideal drink and side. Whether you prefer a cold beer, a glass of wine, or a soda, the right drink can enhance the flavors of your pizza. Similarly, a well-chosen side can turn a simple slice into a satisfying meal.

From garlic knots and mozzarella sticks to chicken wings, french fries, and Caesar salad, Fort Lauderdale’s pizzerias offer a variety of sides to complement your pizza. And when it comes to drinks, whether you’re a fan of sweet white wines, pale ales, or creamy drinks, there’s a perfect pairing for every pizza.

Perfect Pairings on Federal Hwy

Federal Hwy is another hotspot for pizza lovers in Fort Lauderdale. Here, you’ll find a number of restaurants offering a range of drinks and sides to pair with your pizza.

From Belgian Wheat Beer to Manhattan cocktails, there’s a drink for every pizza. And when it comes to sides, options like Caesar salad and Garden Greens salad with sliced chicken cutlet and fresh mozzarella cheese are popular choices. So, whether you’re a fan of cheese pizza or pepperoni pizza, there’s a perfect pairing waiting for you on Federal Hwy.

Exclusive Pizza Tours and Events

For a comprehensive pizza experience, Fort Lauderdale provides exclusive pizza tours and events. These experiences allow you to explore the city’s vibrant pizza scene, tasting a variety of pizzas and learning about their preparation.

From Dolce Salato Pizza & Gelato to Primanti Brothers Restaurant and Luigi’s Coal Oven Pizza, these tours take you to some of the city’s top-rated pizzerias. And for those looking to learn the art of pizza making, Pizzeria Magaddino offers pizza making classes, providing a hands-on experience in crafting the perfect pizza.

Pizza Festivities in the City

One of the highlights of the pizza scene in Fort Lauderdale is the annual Fort Lauderdale Pizza Festival. This event brings together pizza lovers from all over the city to celebrate their love for this universally adored dish.

Held every year on April 1st at the City of Fort Lauderdale War Memorial Auditorium, the Fort Lauderdale Pizza Festival offers a fun-filled day for pizza lovers of all ages. The festival features:

  • A variety of pizzas
  • Local craft beers
  • Live music
  • A special kid zone
  • Pizza eating contests
  • Pizza making workshops

Come and enjoy a day of delicious pizza and great entertainment!  If you are into festivals, make sure to check out the Ft Lauderdale Food & Wine Festival as well!

Other Fort Lauderdale Food Recommendations:

Summary

From New York-style slices to wood-fired wonders, from budget bites to gourmet toppings, and from gluten-free options to late-night haunts, Fort Lauderdale’s pizza scene is as diverse as it is delicious. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, a pizza connoisseur or a casual diner, there’s a slice for everyone in this sun-soaked Florida city. So, why not embark on a pizza journey through Fort Lauderdale and discover a slice of pizza paradise?

Frequently Asked Questions

What are some of the best New York-style pizza joints in Fort Lauderdale?

You should check out Big Louie’s Pizzeria for some delicious New York-style pizza in Fort Lauderdale. Enjoy!

Where can I find authentic Neapolitan pizza in Fort Lauderdale?

You can find authentic Neapolitan pizza at Pizzeria Magaddino on Las Olas Blvd. Enjoy!

Which pizzerias offer budget-friendly pizza options in Fort Lauderdale?

You can find budget-friendly pizza options at Emmy Squared Pizza, Las Olas Pizza, and Jet’s Pizza in Fort Lauderdale. Enjoy your pizza!

Where can I find gluten-free and vegan pizza options in Fort Lauderdale?

You can find gluten-free pizza options at Blaze Pizza, YOLO Restaurant, and Phil’s Heavenly Pizza. For vegan options, check out Pizzeria Magaddino and Sarpino’s Pizzeria. Enjoy your pizza!

Where can I participate in pizza tours and events in Fort Lauderdale?

You can participate in pizza making classes at Pizzeria Magaddino, and enjoy pizza tours at Dolce Salato Pizza & Gelato, Primanti Brothers Restaurant, and Luigi’s Coal Oven Pizza in Fort Lauderdale!

5/5 - (1 vote)

About 

Tim Schmidt is a 20+ year Entrepreneur and Digital Marketer. A Fort Lauderdale-based "Digital Nomad," he enjoys traveling as much as possible with family and friends. AllWorld is his escape to document all of his adventures, including being a hardcore "foodie." He has property in Costa Rica and visits several times each year and is happy to offer his expert advice for planning your trip.

Leave a Comment