Pizza is always a restaurant favorite, and when you are looking for the best pizza in Fort Lauderdale, you have several amazing choices. From Heritage, which has earned a famed Michelin award, to Umberto’s, there is something for everyone on this list.
Key Takeaways
- For authentic Neapolitan flavor: Heritage, Pizzeria Magaddino, and Pummarola.
- For creative, Instagram-worthy pies: Mister O1.
- For late-night eats: Moon Pie Pizza and Primanti Bros.
- For a scenic dining experience: Patio Bar.
- For classic New York vibes: Times Square Pizza and Umberto’s.
- For every craving in between: Fort Lauderdale’s pizza scene truly delivers — one perfect slice at a time.
The Best Fort Lauderdale Pizza Choices
Are you looking for food in Fort Lauderdale? Don’t count out the pizza available in this city. Here’s a list of nine of the very best pizza spots. Craving old-school NY style? Deep dish? Neapolitan? There is something for everyone at these Fort Lauderdale locations.
Heritage – Creating Pizzas from the Finest Ingredients
Located in Fort Lauderdale’s Flagler Village, Heritage has earned a Michelin Bib Gourmand distinction for a reason. The restaurant has the typical salads, pasta, and more, but you want to go for the pizza. Yes, there are pies that are familiar to you, such as pepperoni, sausage, and meatball, but there is also pizza with squash blossoms and cold-pulled burrata on a sherry marinara base.
Whether you are looking for the rich tastes of the short rib marsala pizza or a traditional pie with cupped pepperoni, you will find it here at Heritage.
Mister 01 Extraordinary Pizza – An Amazing Italian Treat
With locations around Florida, including Miami Beach, Naples, and of course, Fort Lauderdale, Mister 01 Extraordinary Pizza serves crisp, thin-crust pizzas prepared in house with amazing intention and technique.
The kitchen pushes out elevated pies from basics like cheese and mushroom to the Mimmo, which takes pizza craft to the next level with spicy salami, sausage, honey, ranch dressing, and black truffles.
Pummarola – My Go-To Neapolitan Pizza Place
If you ware looking for authentic Neapolitan flavors and style, you should definitely check out Pummarola. With wood-fired ovens imported directly from Naples, guests here will believe they are sitting in Italy as they dine on the soft, charred crust, pizza with exceptional flavors.
Pummarola offers the complete package with pizza, pasta, salads, sides, and more, making it a great place to visit, or order online and stay home. Either way, you will love Pummarola.
Pizzeria Magaddino – Hidden Gem and Simple Tastes
You will find Pizzeria Magaddino tucked away inside the Gulf Stream Brewery, perfect for those times when you are craving that classic combo of pizza and beer. You can find all types of pizza here, which is part of the great success of this place. From a ham and fig option to classics like cheese, pepperoni, and even several vegan options, there continues to be something for everyone at Pizzeria Magaddino.
Patio Bar & Pizza – Must Stop Site for Groups and Private Events
Patio Bar & Pizza is a great place for groups, or you can host private events here, which makes it a lot easier to plan an upcoming party or meeting. In addition to the amazing pizza, this place also has the art of cocktail making taken care of.
Pizza, cocktails, and an amazing atmosphere makes Patio Bar & Pizza stand out from the crowd in Fort Lauderdale, FL.
Times Square Pizza – New York-Style Pizza in the Florida Sunshine
If you are looking for the best quality New York-style pizza right here in Fort Lauderdale, make sure to hit up Times Square Pizza. This place has been in the area for more than 20 years, and you will definitely have your hands full when you order a slice or a pie from Times Square Pizza.
Primanti Bros. – Skip the Sandwich and Try the Pizza
Hear me out…I know Primanti Bros. is known for the sandwiches, this place also has amazing pizza. Open 24 hours a day, you can get a slice or a full pie any time….from a random Thursday morning to a late Saturday night.
Moon Pizza Pie – Pizza and Pinball
For a great slice and a unique culture, you definitely need to check out Moon Pizza Pie. Part pinball-lounge and part pizza place, Moon Pie Pizza is just outside of Fort Lauderdale in Oakland Park. If you want something unique, fun, and lively, don’t miss Moon Pizza Pie.
Umberto’s – Ease in and Grab a Slice
While less prominent in online write-ups than some of the others, Umberto’s remains a pick for those in the know who want a no-frills, good slice in the general Fort Lauderdale area. Worth checking out if you’re exploring lesser-trafficked gems.
If you are looking for great Chicago style pizza just went outside of town, I highly recommend Il Baretto in Plantation.
Pizza, Craft Beer, Pinball, and More – Grab a Pizza in Fort Lauderdale
Whether you’re after gourmet toppings and craft beer, authentic Neapolitan dough, or a big NY slice, Fort Lauderdale’s pizza scene has you covered. These nine spots represent some of the best variety in the city—from intimate upscale eateries to lively hangouts.
Next time you’re pizza hunting, try rotating through a few of these. Your tastebuds—and adventurous appetite—will thank you.
About Tim Schmidt
Tim Schmidt is a 20+ year Entrepreneur and Digital Marketer. A Fort Lauderdale-based "Digital Nomad," he enjoys traveling as much as possible with family and friends. AllWorld is his escape to document all of his adventures, including being a hardcore "foodie." He has property in Costa Rica and visits several times each year and is happy to offer his expert advice for planning your trip. Make sure to download the AllWorld Travel Hacks FREE ebook.
