Cayman Islands Non Touristy Activities and Things to See

You’re headed to Grand Cayman, but you’re not one for the typical tourist traps, right? You crave the road less traveled, the hidden gems that give you a true taste of the locale. You’re in luck, there is a treasure trove of things to do that are non-tourist attractions where you can get off Seven mile beach and explore things off the beaten path.

I’ve spent considerable time exploring this Caribbean paradise beyond the beaten path and I’ve got some insider tips to share.

From secluded beaches to local eateries, Grand Cayman is teeming with off-the-grid experiences that’ll leave you with unforgettable memories.

So, forget the crowded resorts and overpriced souvenirs, let’s dive into the real Grand Cayman!

What to Not Miss in Grand Cayman

There’s no shortage of unique experiences in Grand Cayman, all waiting to be explored by the curious traveler. Here’s my take on some must-see attractions and activities you shouldn’t miss.

Explore the Crystal Caves

Nestled within lush tropical forest, the Crystal Caves offer an impressive display of stalactite and stalagmite formations. A guided tour gives a peek into these underground formations, their rich history spanning millions of years. This geological wonder, often overlooked by tourists, indeed deserves a spot in your itinerary.

Discover Wildlife at Queen Elizabeth II Botanic Park

Recognized as a wildlife haven, you’d be amazed at the unique species you’ll encounter at Queen Elizabeth II Botanic Park. From the vibrant Cayman Blue Iguanas, an endangered species native to Grand Cayman, to a myriad of exotic plants, this tranquil setting is teeming with natural beauty. The natural habitat within the park provides a critical breeding ground for the Cayman Blue Iguana, enriching the visitor experience with opportunities to observe these magnificent creatures in a serene environment.

Visit Pedro St. James

Pedro St. James, also known as ‘Pedro Castle,’ provides insight into the island’s history, culture, and architectural heritage. Visitors can stroll through restored historical rooms and watch a 3D multimedia presentation to learn about the pivotal role it played in Grand Cayman’s development.

Connect with Locals at the Farmers & Artisans Market

Held in Camana Bay every Wednesday, the Farmers & Artisans Market is a delightful confluence of local flavors and crafts. It’s the perfect spot to sample local delicacies, purchase handmade crafts, and interact with the island’s residents.

Embark on a Mangrove Forest Kayak Tour

For adventurers, maneuvering through the serene waterways of Grand Cayman’s mangrove forests in a kayak is a rewarding experience. Cayman Kayaks offers unique bioluminescence tours, featuring their electric bio boat experience and informative guides who educate participants about the bioluminescent plankton and their habitats. You’ll get a chance to observe diverse marine life and bird species up-close while enjoying the tranquility of nature.

Remember, the real charm of Grand Cayman lies far beyond the tourist thronged resorts and cruise ship ports. So, venture off the beaten path and uncover the island’s hidden splendors, for a genuinely unforgettable island experience.

The Best Non Touristy Things to Do in Grand Cayman

Savor Afternoon Tea at the Ritz

Indulge in Cayman’s British heritage with an elegant interpretation of this classic English tradition. Featuring dainty English sandwiches, cakes, biscuits, and a grand selection of teas, the Afternoon Tea at the Ritz Carlton encapsulates charm and grandeur. The lobby bar offers alternate beverage choices, if you’d prefer skipping tea and heading straight for champagne.

Bioluminescence Bay

Prepare yourself for a naturally illuminating spectacle as you swim or kayak through warm waters on this captivating nighttime journey. Cayman Kayaks offers a unique electric bio boat experience that allows you to explore the bioluminescence in a safe and informative way.

Keep in mind: for the best underwater light performance, schedule this activity on a dark night, away from a full moon’s glare.

Yoga on Paddleboard

Why stick to a studio when you can practice yoga on clear, shimmering Cayman waters? Kirsten Cousins, renowned Paddleboard and Yoga expert from VitaminSea, is your guide. Her expertise has earned her global recognition as a premier paddleboarding teacher.

Practice Yoga on the Beach

If you’d rather retain more solid footing, join the free community beach yoga class on Sunday mornings at Governor’s beach. This rejuvenating experience is a fantastic way to kick off a Sunday morning — entirely free of charge!

Brunch Time

Refuel post-yoga with a hearty brunch. In Cayman, brunch isn’t just a meal – it’s an event. Dress up and choose from an array of brunch hotspots to suit your mood.

Unwind at a Real Speakeasy

Experience sensual burlesque performances and soulful live music at Next Door. This modern speakeasy offers much more than just great jazz. You’ll find their signature cocktails every bit as enticing as their music schedule.

A Picnic and Road Trip East

Start your journey at The Tasting Room and Cellars for an indulgent selection of Italian delicacies and fine wines. Cemetery Beach is also a peaceful spot for a picnic. Then choose your picturesque picnic spot from some of Cayman’s iconic historic places, including the park at the wreck of the ten sails or the Queen Elizabeth botanic park lake.

Boat Trip to Rum Point/Kaibo

Enjoy a boat ride to the tranquil Rum Point Club, a serene destination perfect for dining and leisure activities, or head to the glamorous Kaibo Beach Club for lunch or dinner. Spend the afternoon in your swimwear, lounging around on their upscale Ibiza-inspired beach daybeds while a live DJ provides the soundtrack to your relaxed afternoon.

You can’t go wrong at any Rum point venue! In fact, I proposed to Michelle at Kaibo!  It was one of the most romantic things to do in Grand Cayman!

Charter a Sailboat for the Day

Experience the pinnacle of VIP enjoyment with a private catamaran sail around the North Sound. Snorkeling gear is essential for enhancing your experience while exploring the vibrant underwater ecosystems. Savor gourmet treats onboard as you journey to meet the stingrays, guided by a private snorkeling expert. If you’re planning a prolonged trip, consider checking out some suggestions for what to take on a sailboat.

>> Here’s a list of charter companies in Cayman.

Explore Natural Wonders

While frequented by tourists, places like the Crystal Caves and the Queen Elizabeth Botanic parks are unmissable highlights due to their natural beauty. These locations are perfect for nature lovers who appreciate exploring lush forests, unique flora and fauna, and engaging in activities like birdwatching and hiking. From the vibrant prints found in the Queen Elizabeth Botanic Park to the spiritually enriching energy of the Crystal Caves, these locations are worth a visit.

Try a New Sport

Active vacationers might enjoy a morning practice session with a golf, tennis, or pickleball pro. Learn something new or indulge in a sport you don’t often find time for at home.

Immerse Yourself in Local Art

Savor the fine work of local artists at The National Gallery of the Cayman Islands. With regularly rotating exhibits, you’ll get a profound glimpse into local island life. The gift shop offers a splendid array of stylish, Island-inspired souvenirs.

Become an Artist

Unleash your creativity at 3 Girls and a Kiln or the popular Art Nest Studio. Their weekly rotating class roster promotes new activities and potential hobbies.

Movie Night

Reserve the VIP Movie theater at Cayman for a private film projection. Enjoy the film on comfy luxury seats, accompanied by pleasing company. Alternatively, revel in a beachside movie screening hosted by The Westin Hotel, complete with a scenic sunset backdrop and dinner service from a beach-front restaurant.

Shopping

Shop till you drop at George Town or Camana Bay. They provide the best shopping avenues, housing a range of local and international brands, boutiques, and upscale hotel shops.

West Indies Wine Company Wine Tasting

Spend a relaxing afternoon or evening sampling a diverse array of wines for a fixed rate. Situated on a cozy courtyard at Camana Bay, you can enjoy your favorite vintage while basking in the vibrant island vibe.

Gelato Enjoyment

Visit one of the best gelato stores worldwide, run by Italian owner Marcella. Grab a gelato and relax on the waterfront, enjoying the coastal ambiance at Camana Bay or George Town.

Day Trip or Overnight Stay on the Sister Islands

Experience life before tourists on the Cayman Brac and Little Cayman islands. Immerse yourself in secluded beaches, explore Owen Island, or climb the striking bluffs of Cayman Brac.

Dance to Your Heart’s Content

Get grooving with Salsa lessons at The Wharf restaurant. Look out for sizzling dance nights or private lessons from skilled teachers at Fuego Latin Dance. For a more elegant choice, take up jazz, pole and aerial dance classes with Quintessential Movement on Seven Mile Beach.

Cook Up a Gourmet Storm

Join fellow food enthusiasts at Bon Vivant’s show kitchen for a private culinary masterclass with the island’s best chefs. Of course, the highlight of the session is relishing the fruits of your labor!

Vintage Book Shopping and Beach Lounging at Tillies

Savor a meal amidst chic, vintage surroundings at Palm Height’s beachfront restaurant, Tillies. Laze around on the beach between courses or find a vintage gem at their delightful bookshop.

Unique Things to Do in Grand Cayman

Having covered quite a few activities in Grand Cayman, I still have a few unique experiences up my sleeve that take you further off the beaten path. Here are some noteworthy picks from the pile:

Hang Out with Stingrays in the Open Sea:
Indeed, it’s popular among visitors, but the Stingray City sandbar remains one of the most captivating experiences in Grand Cayman. This natural sandbar, located in the beautiful North Sound, is home to a crowd of, incredibly friendly, stingrays that don’t shy away from human interaction.

Dine Under the Stars at Yara:
For an unparalleled culinary experience, I recommend Yara Global steakhouse. Nestled in the heart of the Seven Mile Beach resort area, Yara not only serves delectable meals but also runs a ‘Dinner under the Stars’ night where they serve your meal right under the twinkling Caribbean sky.

Pedal Kayaking in Bioluminescent Bay:
While we have already touched on Bioluminescence Bay, I want to bring your attention to the magic that is pedal kayaking in this awe-inspiring natural spectacle. Here, you can pedal your way into the mystic neon glow of the bioluminescent organisms for a truly mesmerizing ride.

Mastic Trail Hiking:
If you’re nature-inclined, trekking the Mastic Trail is for you. Considered the country’s best kept ecological secret, this trail gives you a unique peek into Grand Cayman’s native wildlife and flora. What’s even better? The Mastic Reserve, which the trail traverses, is home to over fifty bird species and some rare, indigenous trees.

This catalogue of activities exudes uniqueness, providing visitors with experiences not possible elsewhere. From swimming with stingrays to dining under the stars at a sophisticated steakhouse, pedal kayaking to hiking trails, there is something on offer for everyone.

Snorkeling:

Okay, this may be not be non touristy, but get some snorkeling gear because you’ll see more species of fish here in the Caribbean sea than you will back home. You can trust me on that one!

Secret Things to Do in Grand Cayman

There’s more to Grand Cayman than what meets the eye. Delve deeper and uncover the secret spots and activities that mainstream tourists often overlook. Splendid wonders waiting to be discovered are ready to offer you an unforgettable Caribbean retreat.

Visit Pedro’s Castle

One of the most intriguing and less crowded historical treasures in Grand Cayman is Pedro St. James, often referred to as Pedro’s Castle. A national historic site, it’s steeped in rich history and past controversies of slave emancipations.

Explore Blooms at the Botanic Park

Queen Elizabeth II Botanic Park, home to a dazzling array of flowering trees, shrubs, and exotic orchids, often gets overlooked by laid-back beach seekers. Take a leisurely stroll among these botanical beauties while you soak in their serenity.

Try Traditional Cayman Delicacies

One way to enrich your island exploration is by tasting local cuisines distinct to Grand Cayman. The Cayman Sunday Roast at traditional beach-side shacks like Heritage Kitchen or The Brasserie are just two examples. Don’t miss trying conch fritters, a local delicacy.

Dive to Kittiwake Shipwreck

Wreck diving in Grand Cayman takes a new meaning with USS Kittiwake, a submerged naval ship that turned artificial reef. It’s a paradise for marine enthusiasts and underwater photographers.

Feed Blue Iguanas

In the Queen Elizabeth II Botanic Park, you’ll find endangered Blue Iguanas. Participate in feeding sessions and help protect these fantastic creatures.

Unwind at Smith’s Cove

After a day filled with explorations, rest under the shade of sea grape trees and unwind at Smith’s Cove, an intimate, hidden beach spot away from the bustling crowds.

Remember, experiences at Grand Cayman aren’t just about the most famous or popular attractions. They are about discovering places off the beaten track and soaking in the authentic island life it offers. Experience the variety, tranquility, and unique activities in your own time, and craft an unforgettable island adventure that’s uniquely yours.

Is Grand Cayman Worth Visiting?

Indeed, Grand Cayman justifies every single travel penny spent. It’s a place where island charm meets sophisticated living, where tranquil coastlines intersect with vibrant life under the sea.  You can read my deeper dive on this topic here.

Rich Cultural Heritage

Pedro St. James, often referred to as the “Birthplace of Democracy” in the Cayman Islands, stands as a testament to the island’s rich history. Here, visitors can take a scenic stroll down memory lane, exploring the grandeur of a traditional Caymanian home.

Blooming Natural Beauty

Remote from the bustling city, the Botanic Park offers a tranquil haven. It’s not just decorated with stunning tropical flora but also provides a habitat for the Blue Iguana, an endangered species endemic to the Caymans.

A Foodie’s Paradise

Grand Cayman showcases an array of local and international cuisines. From the delicious conch stew to the spicy jerk chicken, the island’s culinary landscape is ripe for exploration.

Aquatic Adventures

For the divers, the Kittiwake Shipwreck is a dream come true. Lying 60 feet beneath the turquoise waves, the former submarine rescue ship now houses marine life, making it a top diving attraction.

Peaceful Beach Escapes

Lastly, Smith’s Cove’s secluded beaches offer an idyllic setting away from the crowded tourist spots. The tranquil beach is a quintessential spot for relaxation, sunbathing, or simply appreciating the beauty of the Caribbean Sea.

In summarizing all this, I’d emphasize Grand Cayman presents more than a mere vacation resort. It offers a journey of discovery, a trip beyond commercial attractions, encapsulating cultural experiences, natural wonders, culinary delights, aquatic adventures, and serene beaches.

When to Travel to Cayman Islands

So there you have it – Grand Cayman isn’t just about sunbathing and sipping cocktails by the beach. It’s a place where you can get up close with stingrays, dine under the stars, and dive into a shipwreck. It’s where you can feed Blue Iguanas, bask in the beauty of the Botanic Park, and soak up the history at Pedro St. James. 

Don’t forget to try out the local delicacies and spend some quiet time at Smith’s Cove. These are the experiences that’ll give you a real taste of the Caribbean, far from the madding crowd. So, next time you’re planning a trip, remember Grand Cayman. It’s more than a vacation spot – it’s a journey of discovery. And trust me, it’s a journey worth taking. Safe travels, my friends!